Published: November 24, 2025
On Halloween, the principal of Mt. Blue Middle School in Farmington, Maine, chose to dress as a U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) officer. In photos, Principal James Black is seen wearing a dark vest labeled “POLICE ICE,” a hat with “ICE” printed across the front, and a black-and-white American flag neck gaiter.
Although the photos were reportedly taken at a private gathering, their circulation on social media quickly ignited outrage throughout the district and beyond. For many in the community, especially immigrant families, the imagery was more than just a costume – it was a reminder of real fear.
While some have demanded accountability from the district and called for Black to face consequences for what they view as a serious lapse in judgment, it appears no action has been taken.
“I have received several communications from staff members and others with concerns and/or questions about the matter. As we understand it, this situation occurred off RSU #9 grounds and was not connected to any RSU 9 activities,” said Superintendent Christian Elkington. He added that the situation was being handled “internally.”
We attempted to reach Elkington directly for additional comment, but he did not respond.
Black’s family and friends have pushed back against the criticism, insisting that the photos were taken at a private family event and that the costume was never worn at school. Still, many argue that intent does not erase impact, especially when the imagery involves a federal agency known for separating families and detaining children.
Following the backlash, Principal Black submitted a written letter to the school board and superintendent expressing regret for his choice of costume. He stated that he “regrets” choosing the costume and that it was meant to be “light-hearted.” He also wrote that he did not consider how emotionally charged ICE imagery can be for immigrant students and their families.
On Nov. 18, dozens of people attended a school board meeting in Farmington to share their experiences with Mt. Blue Middle School Principal James Black. During the public comment period, Ed David of Farmington said, “If one child is harmed, that’s too many.”
Others spoke in support of Black, insisting that this single action does not define his character. The room appeared split, with people applauding both sides of the argument. When speakers called for Black to be held accountable and face consequences for actions that may harm immigrant students, numerous people in the predominantly white crowd could be seen laughing and rolling their eyes.
A recording of the meeting can be found on RSU 9’s website.
As the conversation continues in Farmington and throughout the broader community, many are left to ask: What does inclusive leadership look like? How should educators balance their personal lives with their public roles? How can schools ensure that all students, regardless of background, feel genuinely safe and valued?
The district’s eventual response – or lack thereof – will likely shape how families perceive their school leadership going forward.
